In their new article, “Patient-Provider Communication while Using a Clinical Decision Support Tool: Explaining Satisfaction with Shared Decision Making for Mammography Screening,” in BMC Medical Informatics and Decision Making, the Health Information Technology Studies group reveals the importance of patient-provider communication in addition to EHR-integrated decision aids to predict decision-making satisfaction.
Clinical decision aids may support shared decision-making for screening mammography. To inform shared decision-making between patients and their providers, this study examines how patterns of using an EHR-integrated decision aid and accompanying verbal patient-provider communication predict decision-making satisfaction.
For 51 patient visits during which a mammography decision aid was used, linguistic characteristics of patient-provider verbal communication were extracted from transcribed audio recordings and system logs automatically captured uses of the decision aid. Surveys assessed patients’ post-visit decisional satisfaction and its subcomponents. Linear mixed effects models assessed how patients’ satisfaction with decision making was related to patterns of verbal communication and navigation of the decision aid.
The results indicate that providers’ use of quantitative language during the encounter was positively associated with patients’ overall satisfaction, feeling informed, and values clarity. Patients’ question-asking was negatively associated with overall satisfaction, values clarity, and certainty perception. Where system use data indicated the dyad had cycled through the decision-making process more than once (“looping” back through pages of the decision aid), patients reported improved satisfaction with shared decision making and all subcomponents. Overall satisfaction, perceived support, certainty, and perceived effectiveness of decision-making were lowest when a high number of navigating clicks occurred absent “looping.”
Linguistic features of patient-provider communication and system use data of a decision aid predict patients’ satisfaction with shared decision making. Our findings have implications for the design of decision aid tools and clinician training to support more effective shared decision-making for screening mammography.
Full citation: “Patient-Provider Communication while Using a Clinical Decision Support Tool: Explaining Satisfaction with Shared Decision Making for Mammography Screening,” Yan Liu, Rachel Kornfield, Ellie Fan Yang, Elizabeth Burnside, Jon Keevil and Dhavan V. Shah, BMC Medical Informatics and Decision Making, 22: (323) December 2022. DOI: 10.1186/s12911-022-02058-3.
Full article available through BMC.